Big Data Analytics Solutions | Financial Services in India |Decimal Point Analysis

Decimal Blog

Customized, Optimized and Enhanced research operations


  • Excessive Monetary Tightening in India as compared to OECD

    July 17, 2017
    Singularity is the biggest threat

    In this note we will see how behavior of RBI in recent years is proving a relative impediment to economic growth.

    In order to analyze inflation, this author prefers to study behavior of GDP deflator over a period of three years. The chart below shows the excess of three year CAGR of Indian GDP deflator over OECD GDP deflator.

    Chart 1: Excess Indian GDP Deflator over OECD Deflator

    Source: Decimal Point Analytics

    The above measure has many advantages. Firstly, three year CAGR envelops and hence smoothens out the effect of vagaries of Indian monsoons. Secondly, by subtracting OECD GDP deflator from Indian GDP deflator, we remove effects of global commodity and energy super cycles, which affects all of the countries to differing extents. Thus, what we are left with is only the structural constraints in Indian economy at given level growth of economic activity leading to inflation. As clearly shown by the chart, in last three years, as the new administration took over and removed obstacles for commerce, especially in farm sector, the excess GDP deflator has shown a clear downward trend in India, showing that, possibly, other things being equal, the Indian economy has moved to a permanent relative lower inflation trajectory as long as current administrative policies remain in force.

    Now, let us see how the policy rates in India have responded, on relative basis to this long term, secular, structural (and possibly sustainable) softening of inflation in India. The chart below shows Indian Central Bank policy rates minus average OECD policy rates at the end of each year.

    Chart 2: Excess Indian Policy Rates over OECD

    Source: Decimal Point Analytics

    If we subtract Chart 1 from Chart 2, we will get relative real interest rates in India as compared to OECD, as shown in the chart below.

    Chart 3: Relative Real Interest Rates in India as compared to OECD

    Source: Decimal Point Analytics

    The last chart clearly shows that, on relative basis, Indian central bank was somewhat accommodative in 2010 with negative relative interest rates, and by the end of 2016, RBI had moved to extreme tight monetary policy with real rates nearing four percentage points on relative basis.

    In our view, in normal, middle of business and economic cycle, there is no economic logic for the relative real rates between two countries (or groups of countries) to vary beyond +/-0.50%. In other words, it is possible that history will determine that current monetary policy in India is too tight by three to four percentage points as compared to OECD.


Decimal Point Analytics (DPA) will process the information in this form to share information as requested. By checking the above box you confirm your acceptance to receive the communication. You can unsubscribe any time by clicking the ‘Unsubscribe’ link in the footer of any email you receive from us, or by contacting us at

We use cookies to measure website performance, provide social media features and personalize content.
Close this dialog to confirm you are happy with that, or find out more in the privacy statement.